High School

Explain how or why it can be argued that gerrymandering is undemocratic.

Answer :

Final answer:

Gerrymandering manipulates electoral district boundaries to favor one party, undermining democratic principles by distorting fair representation. This practice reduces electoral competitiveness and accountability, with the Supreme Court's decision on partisan gerrymandering leaving the issue unresolved. Some states have sought to combat gerrymandering by establishing independent commissions to draw district lines fairly.

Explanation:

Gerrymandering is the practice of redrawing legislative district boundaries to favor one political party, making it a contentious issue in democratic societies. By manipulating district lines, gerrymandering undermines the principle of fair representation, allowing elected officials to choose their constituents rather than constituents choosing their officials. This manipulation distorts the democratic process, making it harder for voters to effect change and institutionalize political power within a specific party, thereby reducing electoral competitiveness and accountability.

Partisan gerrymandering, in particular, has been highlighted as a significant challenge to the integrity of elections. This form of gerrymandering uses advanced geo-mapping and big data technologies to create districts that significantly disadvantage the opposition party. Although the Supreme Court has ruled against gerrymandering based on racial discrimination, it has been less willing to intervene in cases of partisan gerrymandering, referring to it as a "political question" and leaving the issue to state legislatures to resolve. This stance has been criticized for enabling an "anti-democratic practice" and effectively disenfranchising millions of American voters.

In response to the challenges of gerrymandering, some states have taken action by removing the power to draw district boundaries from partisan legislatures and placing it in the hands of independent commissions. The goal is to create more competitive districts and ensure fairer electoral outcomes, combatting the negative effects of gerrymandering on American politics.

Other Questions